On February 26, 2024, Checkpoint Charlie in Berlin, historically marked by Cold War tensions, became the backdrop for an unregistered pro-Palestinian protest. Among various chants, the phrase "We want 48" resonated distinctly, not only for its vocal strength but also for its profound and divisive implications. The lack of intervention by local authorities, who monitored the rally without intervening, highlights the contentious nature of this event.

The slogan "We want 48" might seem a mere historical reference to those unfamiliar. However, its implications are extensive and deeply contentious. This chant transcends a call for justice or the pursuit of a peaceful resolution; it represents a stark opposition to the existence of the State of Israel, established in 1948. Such rhetoric extends beyond political debate or ideological differences, striking at the core of Jewish self-determination. This principle, enshrined in international law, reflects the Jewish people's long history of resilience in the face of centuries of persecution, culminating in the Holocaust. The founding of Israel was not just a significant historical event but also a refuge for Jews worldwide.

By uttering "We want 48," demonstrators at Checkpoint Charlie implicitly contested the legitimacy of a nation born amidst existential threats. The chant does not invite dialogue or seek compromise; somewhat, it negates Israel's right to exist.